↓Skip to main content

Novum Mid-2022 – 2024 Operations Manager

Winning SEO clients with cold email and free audits

From mid-2022 I helped Burkhard build Novum's client pipeline: lead lists, the sending setup, cold email and a free audit for every interested prospect. Eight clients signed in 2023.

Cold emailSalesSEO
19,081 cold emails, Apr 2022 to Mar 2023
~46 SEO proposals, Nov 2021 to Dec 2023
8 clients signed in 2023

The problem

Burkhard wanted more clients for Novum Plus, the agency’s done-for-you SEO service, and the agency already knew how to send cold email at scale from its link building.

What I built

  • Lead lists from Sales Navigator and other sources, kept in Google Sheets.
  • The sending setup, rebuilt on Smartlead in 2023 ( the cold email case study).
  • The emails. Every sequence opened with a free traffic projection for the prospect’s site: “Traffic Projection for [company] (372% Growth)”.
  • A free audit for every reply. Prospects who answered got a Top10 analysis or a “Biggest Organic Growth Levers” doc, then a numbered proposal.
  • The people. I hired and screened sales help in August and September 2022, and ran some of the sales calls.

From cold email to kickoff: Zirtual

Zirtual is the one client whose whole path, from first cold email to first invoice, is on record.

1. The cold email

On 9 November 2022 one of our six campaigns, “Sai3”, sent the “Traffic Projection” email to the chief marketing officer of Startups.com, Zirtual’s parent company. It was one of 238 sends that day. The send log shows his reply the same afternoon, about seven hours later.

The send log row for the cold email, 9 November 2022. Contact masked, other rows are sample data. Recreated, original data private.
The send log row for the cold email, 9 November 2022. Contact masked, other rows are sample data. Recreated, original data private.

2. The first free audit

The next day, 10 November, I wrote a Top10 analysis of startups.com, with a short walkthrough video. It led with four growth levers: content the market searches for, links to money pages, A+ content and lead nurturing.

Top10 analysis of startups.com, 10 November 2022. Recreated, original data private.
Top10 analysis of startups.com, 10 November 2022. Recreated, original data private.

3. The audit for Zirtual

On 21 November I wrote a second Top10 analysis, for zirtual.com itself. It found a Domain Rating of 71, a search term with 3,700 visits a month in traffic potential, and blog posts scoring 30 out of 100 for content.

Top10 analysis of zirtual.com, 21 November 2022. Recreated, original data private.
Top10 analysis of zirtual.com, 21 November 2022. Recreated, original data private.

4. Onboarding questions

On 7 and 8 December Zirtual answered our questions doc: their competitors, the clients they serve and the topics they wanted covered. Their folder in our client Drive opened the same day as “007 zirtual.com”.

Zirtual's answers to our onboarding questions, December 2022. Recreated, original data private.
Zirtual's answers to our onboarding questions, December 2022. Recreated, original data private.

5. Kickoff

On 3 January 2023 I wrote: “As discussed, we’ve officially kickstarted Zirtual’s SEO campaign.” The email carried the first invoice and the first content calendar and backlink tracker. Three days later Zirtual sent a test transfer before paying.

The kickoff email and the test-transfer note, January 2023. Recreated, original data private.
The kickoff email and the test-transfer note, January 2023. Recreated, original data private.

The result

  • The campaigns sent 19,081 cold emails in 11 months, and the agency wrote about 46 proposals.
  • Eight clients signed in 2023: Zirtual, Cyngn, Vector, TimePlus, Foreignerds, Catena, Trace and Prosple.
  • Zirtual shows the whole path. A cold email went out on 9 November 2022 and the reply came the same day. Two audits followed, and on 3 January 2023 I wrote: “As discussed, we’ve officially kickstarted Zirtual’s SEO campaign.”

By 2024 demand for SEO had cooled, free trials stopped converting, and the agency moved its effort to Genius.

Email me the process you’d hand off first. In my working hours I reply within 30 minutes.
Email me ckwater123@gmail.com LinkedIn