↓Skip to main content

Novum Jun 2021 – 2024 Link builder, then Operations Manager

Running an agency's cold email, 2021 to 2024

Novum ran on cold email. From 2021 to 2024 Burkhard and I moved its sending from one mailbox in Pitchbox to 15 Office 365 mailboxes in Smartlead, and rebuilt it in March 2023 after an expert's tests showed our mail landing in spam.

Cold emailDeliverabilitySmartleadCopywriting
19,081 client cold emails, Apr 2022 to Mar 2023

The problem

Every link Novum sold and every client it won started with a cold email. I sent my first guest-post pitch on 14 June 2021, and by 2023 the agency sent from dozens of mailboxes across lookalike domains such as novumhq.net and novumhub.com.

In March 2023 our warmup tool said our emails reached the inbox. I booked a one-hour consulting call with GlockApps, a deliverability testing company, on 13 March 2023. Two days later the expert sent his findings: “Your warmup tool says the emails are inboxing but the Glockapps tests show that they are landing in the spam folder.”

What changed

  • Smartlead. I signed the agency up on 30 March 2023 and connected about 12 mailboxes the same day, moving off Sales.Rocks.
  • Fewer mailboxes per domain. We cut to one or two per domain, as the call advised.
  • Lower volume. Each mailbox started at a few emails a day and stepped up slowly.
  • Office 365. We tried it next to Zoho and Google Workspace, and I asked GlockApps for help setting it up on 27 April 2023.
  • List checks. Every lead list went through Debounce before sending.

Burkhard and I built the rules together. I connected the mailboxes, ran the campaigns and brought in the expert.

How the setup changed, 2021 to 2024

Most of the work was keeping mail out of spam day after day. This is how the sending setup moved from hand work to tools, by date.

WhenWhat changed
May 2021I sent from Pitchbox in my own mailbox, under Burkhard’s name, up to 150 emails a day per campaign.
Sep 2021Manual three-step pitches from Mailshake.
Feb to Aug 2022Sales.Rocks sent and warmed the mailboxes with its built-in warmer, until Burkhard removed the warming on 2 August.
Sep 2022Every lead list went through Debounce before sending.
17 Mar 2023After the GlockApps call, I sorted 103 lead domains by their mail host: Google, Microsoft or other.
30 Mar 2023Smartlead: 10 mailboxes, 30 new leads each, 300 emails a day, two follow-ups three days apart, sent as plain text with tracking off.
Jun 2023From 25 Zoho mailboxes, two per domain at 50 a day, to 15 Office 365 mailboxes, one per domain at 90 a day. Both sets warmed at 40 a day, rising by 5.
Apr 2024Warmup Inbox scored our mailboxes 90 to 92 a week.
May 2024Fallbacks for empty merge fields (20 May), one shared inbox in Spark for replies (23 May), and a VA running the Debounce checks.
The Smartlead upload sheet, Zoho mailboxes against Office 365, June 2023. Addresses and passwords masked. Recreated, original data private.
The Smartlead upload sheet, Zoho mailboxes against Office 365, June 2023. Addresses and passwords masked. Recreated, original data private.

The copy

In 2021 every guest-post pitch used one agency template, written in March 2021 before I joined: “Hey [first name] | Quick question regarding [website]”, three emails, the same for every site. In 2023 I wrote eight new campaigns in Burkhard’s voice, since every email went out under his name, and he reviewed them in the docs.

  • Four client campaigns (February to September 2023), each built on one idea: “HubSpot” ("[Name] - Is [Company] the next HubSpot? ($2.12B ARR)"), “Grocery Store” (“You’re inside the grocery store. You see oranges. Three options, [Name] - $5, $3, or $0 for a bag of oranges.”), “Traffic Projection”, offering a free traffic forecast, and “Clutch”, two versions for agencies listed on Clutch.
  • Four guest-post campaigns (collected in one doc in October 2023, next to the 2021 template). Two open with a pun: “[first name] likes traffic like I like orange juice… …to be organic.” The last two changed the offer to free links from DR60–90+ sites plus a ready guest post, and added a way out: “If this isn’t for you just reply ’not interested’.”

Each campaign has a subject with the prospect’s name or company in it, one offer, proof in the follow-ups (Novum’s case studies, or links to our posts on Flippa, Sumo and Lucky Orange), and two to four follow-ups. On 9 October 2023 Burkhard flagged one of my subject lines with “@christian - wrong”.

Guest-post Campaign 4, October 2023, merge fields marked. Recreated, original data private.
Guest-post Campaign 4, October 2023, merge fields marked. Recreated, original data private.
Burkhard's review comment on a subject line, 9 October 2023. Recreated, original data private.
Burkhard's review comment on a subject line, 9 October 2023. Recreated, original data private.

One campaign, end to end

The agency campaign of 19 to 27 March 2024: 247 SEO agency leaders, one email with a personal video, seven replies.

1. The sending domains

Novum sent from lookalike domains such as novumhq.net, novumhq.co and novumhq.org, two mailboxes each, and logged inbox placement for every mailbox in the tracker. In the copy of 28 November 2023 the client mailboxes read “Not Spam” or 99%.

The sending-domain table in the agency tracker, November 2023. Mailbox names masked. Recreated, original data private.
The sending-domain table in the agency tracker, November 2023. Mailbox names masked. Recreated, original data private.

2. Warmup and upkeep

Smartlead kept every mailbox warming with automatic back-and-forth emails, tagged “wuI” in the subject. In March 2024 it also flagged four mailboxes that had dropped off, on 2, 4, 13 and 18 March, the weeks before the send.

Smartlead disconnect alerts and warmup emails in my inbox, March to April 2024. Recreated, original data private.
Smartlead disconnect alerts and warmup emails in my inbox, March to April 2024. Recreated, original data private.

3. The list, checked by Debounce

On 18 March 2024 a list of agency leaders came out of Sales Navigator and went through Debounce the same day. Of 188 addresses, 124 came back safe to send, 56 risky (the domain accepts any address) and 8 unknown.

The Debounce result file, 18 March 2024. Counts are real, rows are sample data. Recreated, original data private.
The Debounce result file, 18 March 2024. Counts are real, rows are sample data. Recreated, original data private.

4. A personal video for each lead

We recorded one video and Sendspark made a personal link for each lead, with the prospect’s own website as the background. The upload file of 22 March held a video link per row.

The Sendspark upload: one personal video link per lead. Recreated, original data private.
The Sendspark upload: one personal video link per lead. Recreated, original data private.

5. The sequence

One step, sent as Burkhard, asking for a reaction to the video and signing off with the lead’s city. The city field was blank for 132 of the 247 leads, so more than half the emails read “Sending love to ,”. On 20 May 2024 I asked Smartlead how to set a fallback for empty merge fields.

The blank sign-off, and Smartlead's answer on fallbacks, May 2024. Recreated, original data private.
The blank sign-off, and Smartlead's answer on fallbacks, May 2024. Recreated, original data private.
The one email in the sequence, as the campaign export shows it. Recreated, original data private.
The one email in the sequence, as the campaign export shows it. Recreated, original data private.

6. The send and the replies

Smartlead sent all 247 emails from 19 to 27 March 2024. Seven people replied: five out-of-office notes, one “No thanks” and one who said he no longer read that inbox. None became a call. The video page logged 82 views from 19 March to 8 April, a few of them from outside this list, so more people watched than replied.

The campaign report, exported 28 March 2024. Totals and reply text are real. Recreated, original data private.
The campaign report, exported 28 March 2024. Totals and reply text are real. Recreated, original data private.

The result

  • The client outreach sent 19,081 cold emails between April 2022 and March 2023.
  • Eight campaigns of new copy in 2023, four for clients and four for guest-post hosts.
  • The setup kept needing care. Smartlead flagged disconnected mailboxes again from December 2023 to March 2024.

What I’d change

I’d build the sending setup first. The business ran on cold email, and when sending broke, revenue slowed with it. I’d also measure reply rates from day one, so I’d have the before and after in numbers.

Email me the process you’d hand off first. In my working hours I reply within 30 minutes.
Email me ckwater123@gmail.com LinkedIn